|
The 8th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution
prohibits punishments that are cruel and unusual. The
8th Amendment is often invoked in death penalty cases,
but it also addresses excessive fines. It applies to
both federal and state governments, but most states
actually have stricter cruel and unusual punishment
laws.
Examples
Some examples of cruel and unusual punishments
include:
- Incarceration merely because of a physical or
mental condition
- A 14-year sentence for assault with a deadly
weapon
- Requiring someone who exposed himself in a
non-threatening manner to register as a sex
offender
- Life imprisonment for passing a bad check, which
was the defendant's seventh non-violent felony
Death Penalty
Death as a punishment for a crime is not itself
unconstitutional. Death is not automatically regarded
as cruel and unusual, but the way it is applied must
meet very specific requirements.
For example, a state may not impose the death penalty
if society generally agrees that the death penalty is
inappropriate for that particular crime. But if the
state provides rational guidelines to help juries
decide if the death penalty is appropriate, and if the
jury is allowed to take in mitigating factors, then
application of the death penalty will probably be
upheld.
Excessive Fines
Government is also prohibited from imposing
excessive fines as punishment for a crime. To
determine if a fine is excessive, courts look at
whether the fine is grossly disproportionate to the
seriousness of the offense. Therefore, the more
serious the crime (such as murder), the higher the
fine may be.
|