|
The Fifth Amendment of the U.S Constitution has
created volumes of discussion, analysis, and
criticism. The primary protection afforded by the
Fifth Amendment is the right against
self-incrimination.
Self-Incrimination
The thrust of the Fifth Amendment is to prevent the
government, or any of its affiliates, from coercing
confessions from people. At first, this mainly
consisted of physical coercion, though today it also
includes psychological coercion.
Involuntary confessions are patently unconstitutional,
and admission of such confessions into evidence could
lead to reversible error (reversal of a conviction
primarily upon the involuntary confession).
Miranda Rights
Since 1966, the Miranda rights have been part of the
American landscape. Many people have the mistaken
impression that immediately upon being arrested they
must be informed of their Miranda rights. That is
simply not so. The U.S. Supreme Court, in its decision
in the Miranda case, simply requires that once a
person is in police custody, he/she may not be
questioned until advised of his/her rights and agrees
to waive them.
If the police violate Miranda, any answers given will
not be admissible at trial. It is interesting to point
out that if a person, even while in custody,
volunteers or just blurts out a statement, the
statement can be used in court against him/her.
Pursuant to Miranda, while in custody of police,
you must be informed of the following:
- The right to remain silent – Once this
right is invoked, the police may not continue to
interrogate you.
- The right to have an attorney present during
interrogation – If this right is invoked,
police must stop interrogating you until your
attorney is present to advise you.
- The right to a court-appointed attorney
– If you cannot afford an attorney, the court
will typically appoint one for you at the public's
expense.
- Explanation that what you say can be used
against you.
- The right to stop interrogation – If
you are arrested and agree to be questioned, you
may stop the interrogation until you have an
attorney present.
- Waiver of rights – You may waive these
rights at any time.
|