|
There are 2 ways in which a prosecutor can initiate
criminal charges. Both involve presenting evidence
that shows likelihood that the accused is guilty. One
of these ways is through a grand jury.
A grand jury is a group of people, ranging from 11
to 23, who hear evidence against a defendant and
decide if the case should proceed to trial. Their
responsibility is not to determine if the defendant is
guilty or innocent, but to decide if there are enough
facts to support a charge against the defendant.
Who Can Be a Grand Juror?
A grand jury is a group of qualified people who are
citizens of the county where the case is being tried.
To qualify as a grand juror, a person must be:
- A citizen of the United States
- At least 18 years old
- A resident of the county for at least one year
before being selected
- Of ordinary intelligence
- In possession of his or her natural faculties
- Of sound judgment and fair character
- English speaking
- Not serving as a trial juror or a public officer
Grand jurists are pre-selected before the beginning
of the fiscal year by a jury commissioner and are
selected from areas of the county in proportion to
their population.
Role of the Grand Jury
Grand juries are used in lieu of holding a preliminary
hearing for the defendant. The prosecutor (usually a
district attorney) presents evidence and witnesses
before the jury and attempts to make out a skeleton
case for the charged offenses.
If the grand jury finds that the evidence, if
uncontradicted, would warrant a conviction by a trial
jury, they “indict,” or bring formal charges
against, the defendant.
The Controversy of Grand Juries
Grand juries have come under fire from commentators
because many people believe that the grand jury is
biased: only the prosecutor is allowed to present
evidence, and the jury must assume that the evidence
is true.
Additionally, grand juries do not have to follow
standard rules of evidence as trial juries do. For
example, a grand jury is allowed to base their
indictment on a police officer relating hearsay. In
addition, some types of inadmissible evidence will not
invalidate the indictment.
|